COVID-19 and asylum seekers

The unbearable lightness of asylum seekers’ life in times of a pandemic.

Like many other people, I wasn’t too sure what to think of the pandemic at the start. I was convinced it was another type of flue, nothing too bad. But when I saw the numbers of people dying, the speed of contamination, I soon changed my mind. This one is like nothing I have ever seen or experienced before.

So here it is, the pandemic scientists have been warning for many years. It has arrived.

One of my first thoughts was how they would ever keep COVID19 out of busy, shared workspaces such as call centres, which I, unfortunately, know all too well.

And then my mind went to the Direct Provision Centres, with its shared rooms, shared bathrooms, canteens, recreation areas. I tweeted about it, asking Charlie Flanagan and HSE what they were going to do about them, how will they apply social distancing in these places? No answer, of course. A few retweets, but that was it.Screenshot (114)

A resident of one of the centres then sent me a video, showing nothing but empty hand sanitiser containers in his centre. Now that made me mad! I tweeted it, and then shared the video with my colleagues on the City of Sanctuary movement’s executive committee, we decided to set up a task force, wrote a letter to the mayor and other important people in the City council and the government, and made an action plan and started a petition asking to move vulnerable people out, move families out and to provide accommodation outside for health care workers and other frontline workers.

We moved on to set up informal resident’s platforms, got meetings with the HSE inclusion team and set up a Connect Call service for residents.

We were working together as a team, all passionate, and full of enthusiasm.

We got the news that the Department of Justice had provided 650 rooms for people who needed self-isolation and some new places to ‘thin out’ overpopulated DP centres. Hand sanitisers were finally provided.

It all sounded too good to be true…. and indeed it was.

Here is what is really happening.

  • One of the requests of residents in DP was to get kitchen rolls instead of one dishcloth, shared by everyone. I didn’t want to wait another two weeks to get those and asked friends for help. we contacted a local charity which offers food to the needy. The manager immediately said she could help. She prepared a delivery of kitchen rolls, but added food hampers as well and delivered all this the same day. I couldn’t be there because of travel restrictions, but I heard afterwards that the manager of the centre had caused a scene and wanted to send this lady back.  She couldn’t of course. This lady knows how to defend herself. She has every right to offer residents food hampers. And residents do need them, they often cook for themselves, as the food in the canteen is not always nice and they also prefer not to go to the canteen during the pandemic.


  • Health care workers are being moved to rooms in hotels. No fridge in the room.  They get served food that they’d rather not eat, and often just go hungry instead. There is no communication between these health care workers and the HSE. One of them did not know that he could ask the reception of the hotel to do his laundry because no one told him. This man is used to cook for himself, but now he can’t, and instead, he has to eat breakfast and dinner served in cardboard boxes and left in front of his door.



He often works night shifts, but his meals are not adapted. Why, oh why are they not putting the healthy, well able health care workers in self-catering places? I know of some of them who have refused to go and live in a hotel, because of these reasons, they have lost their job and being residents of DP centres, they are not entitled to COVID-19 payments.

  • The information we got from HSE Inclusion was always very positive. They are working hard. But not everything is always that rosey and it was also quite clear that criticism wasn’t kindly accepted.


  • I noticed that people had indeed been moved to thin out the population of overcrowded DP centres. In Glenvera, for example, there are still 3 people in a room, (before there would be up to 7) sharing bathrooms, dining rooms, recreation areas. How would they social distance? well, the simple answer is, they don’t.

Here is what one of the residents there said: “Keeping social distance is impossible in the accommodation centre as we share things and have not enough space”.

  • -I was contacted by a person with an underlying condition, who felt extremely depressed and was very anxious and worn out worrying about the Corona Virus. He is still sharing a room. We were told by the HSE inclusion team that, if a person belongs to a vulnerable group, the public nurse would treat this on a case-by-case basis. The PHN would make contact with the DOJ to either make sure this resident would get a single room or, if not possible, transfer the person to a location outside of DP, to cocoon or self-isolate., which sounds great.  So I advised him to contact the PHN.

He called me back, the nurse had told him that it would be very difficult and asked if I could contact her. I called her and she told me, that so far, she hasn’t had any luck with the Justice Department, nor with IPAS. She asked me if I could take charge of this. In the end, I got help from the Irish Refugee Council who is now fighting his case.

  • Recently the content of a newsletter form IPAS to the residents of DP centres was shared in the taskforce’s WhatsApp group. It was clearly intended to be read by residents. So I asked if they had seen it. The answer was no. Not one of the residents in Kinsale Road, Glenverra, Macroom or Clonakilty had heard of a newsletter coming from IPAS, although it contains important info. It seems that apart from writing on a website that no resident follows, no effort is being made to share content that could be of interest to residents. I shared the content with all of them. But I also decided that I will not do IPAS’ work again after this. I am sure they have a well-paid communications team.

And so it goes on and on. Families are still living in tiny spaces with their children, in some of the hotels, single mothers share the same room with their teenage children, both girls and boys. They are finding it extremely difficult. They need an appartment, not a room.

  • The decision to test everyone in DP centres was made, in itself a good decision, but none of the residents was given any explanation, some were told the day before, without explaining or without being given the chance to ask any questions. It was up to us to explain, which we did in a voice message and videos from Sanctuary runners founder, Graham Clifford.

It seems quite clear to me that the government did react (too slow, reluctantly, but under pressure) to the petitions and press actions, but they did it wrong. They acted on a national level, dealing with numbers, not with people. They acted but did not do enough, hence the recent outbreak of COVID-19 in Cahersiveen, and the announcement that there are 10 clusters of Covid19 and 62 positive tests in DP centres 11 of them have been hospitalised.

There is a serious lack of communication between the stakeholders and a serious lack of empathy and humanity in the way they deal with asylum seekers. Moving them from one county to another without any warning, Putting them in hotels and leaving them to their own device there. And then leaving them in circumstances that are not right at all, not in everyday life and certainly not during a pandemic.

If this crisis has shown one thing it is that the Direct Provision centres are not fit for purpose, that hotel managers should not be given the management roll of centres for refugees and that working at a local level would have been a lot better than trying to organise numbers.

I understand that the HSE is doing its best, but they have no need in promoting themselves to us on the frontline, they need to be honest and open. If something doesn’t work, just say it doesn’t work, be transparent.

Do not mistake an activist for a social worker. there are differences.

Keeping asylum seekers safe is keeping everyone safe. As the WHO said, we are all in this together. Let’s make sure we mean it.










Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.